For Rent


If, at any time, you have trouble booking a property, please don't hesitate to call us at (631) 788-7921 or send us an email at info@shuttersandsails.com and we will be happy to complete the booking for you.

Below is a summary of the properties that are available and fit your search criteria.
Not all properties are listed on-line. If you don't find what you like, please call us for help.
27 records found

Prev 1  2  Next
Osprey Hill Cottage Weekly Rent Range   
Osprey Hill Cottage- More info 6600-6600
Bedrooms:
Sleeps:
Montauk Cottage Weekly Rent Range   
Montauk Cottage- Charming 1 bedroom cottage located in the Village. A great place to relax while being close to everything More info (please call)-(please call)
Bedrooms:
Sleeps:
Rabbit Run Cottage Weekly Rent Range   
Rabbit Run Cottage- Cozy 1 bedroom cottage with pull out queen sofa in the living room. Efficiency kitchen, wood burning stove, large yard with seating area and partial water views. More info 2500-2500
Bedrooms:
Sleeps:
Treetops Weekly Rent Range   
Treetops- This is a small comfortable centrally located cottage. Easy walk to center of town and Hay Harbor Club. Convenient to ferry, Hay Harbor Golf Club and Fishers Island Yacht Club. More info 2500-3000
Bedrooms:
Sleeps:
Isabella Cottage Weekly Rent Range   
Isabella Cottage- This romantic summer cottage on the east end of Fishers Island has water views and access to uncrowded beaches. Enjoy nature from the deck overlooking the pond or strolling on the grounds that are part of a larger estate. There are three bedrooms and More info 3300-3500
Bedrooms:
Sleeps:
Hill Cottage Weekly Rent Range   
Hill Cottage- This charming, four bedroom cottage is tucked into the West End's North Hill neighborhood. An easy walk to town, the grocery store and Dock Beach make this house convenient for everyone. A separate garage apartment features an additional bedroom, and More info 2800-2800
Bedrooms:
Sleeps:
Walker House Weekly Rent Range   
Walker House- Nature abounds this private modern getaway with wrap-around enclosed porch for dining and relaxing. The open concept design and vaulted ceilings welcomes family and friends to enjoy spacious comfort. The home is well maintained and located within min More info 3800-3800
Bedrooms:
Sleeps:
Braun House Weekly Rent Range   
Braun House- More info 5500-5833
Bedrooms:
Sleeps:
The Cabin Weekly Rent Range   
The Cabin- This cozy vacation rental is located near the four corners on the east end of Fishers Island - down the road from Isabella Beach. It has an open floor plan with a combined kitchen, dining, and living room. There's also a separate family room and a la More info 3300-3500
Bedrooms:
Sleeps:
Leeway Weekly Rent Range   
Leeway- More info 5500-6000
Bedrooms:
Sleeps:
Roberts Folly Weekly Rent Range   
Roberts Folly- More info 5000-6000
Bedrooms:
Sleeps:
Harbourscape Weekly Rent Range   
Harbourscape- Newer home with lots of space for the family and entertaining . Perched on a hill it has a commanding view of West Harbor, Pirates Cove and Fishers Island Sound, and… stunning sunrises. Although just a short walk to the yacht club, shops and the vill More info 7500-7500
Bedrooms:
Sleeps:
KinderHaus Weekly Rent Range   
KinderHaus- This great three season house has a wonderful open floor plan. The view from the kitchen, living and dining area is spectacular looking out towards Block Island and Long Island. The outside porch runs completely along the entire south side of the hou More info 3750-3750
Bedrooms:
Sleeps:
Yellow House Weekly Rent Range   
Yellow House- One of the coveted houses along historic Officer's Row, the Yellow House offers amentities you'd expect in a modern house, while being a beautifully kept 1902 officer's home in the Fort H. G. Wright neighborhood. With a cozy fireplace in the newly cr More info 6000-6000
Bedrooms:
Sleeps:
Abby's Cottage Weekly Rent Range   
Abby This adorable Cape has tasteful coastal d?cor and classic cottage charm. Located on a quiet cul-de-sac near the library, and close to town. You are just steps away from everything island life has to offer. Wash away the sand after a day at the beach More info 3300-3300
Bedrooms:
Sleeps:
Island House Weekly Rent Range   
Island House- More info 2500-2500
Bedrooms:
Sleeps:
Zinnia Hill Weekly Rent Range   
Zinnia Hill- More info 3800-3800
Bedrooms:
Sleeps:
Braemar Weekly Rent Range   
Braemar- Braemar is a house rich in history. Named after a small town in Scotland, it was built in the early 1880?s and considered to be one of the original ?Bartlett? cottages on the island. Located just blocks from the village green, this house is centrally More info 3200-3400
Bedrooms:
Sleeps:10 
Brooks Point House Weekly Rent Range   
Brooks Point House- More info 7000-7900
Bedrooms:
Sleeps:10 
Fort House Weekly Rent Range   
Fort House- One of the coveted houses along historic Officer's Row, the Fort House offers the modern amentities you'd expect in a modern home in a beautifully kept 1890's officer's home in the west end's Fort H. G. Wright neighborhood. With a stunning covered wr More info (please call)-(please call)
Bedrooms:
Sleeps:10 

Prev 1  2  Next