For Rent


If, at any time, you have trouble booking a property, please don't hesitate to call us at (631) 788-7921 or send us an email at info@shuttersandsails.com and we will be happy to complete the booking for you.

Below is a summary of the properties that are available and fit your search criteria.
Not all properties are listed on-line. If you don't find what you like, please call us for help.
23 records found

Prev 1  2  Next
Pirates Cove Cottage Weekly Rent Range   
Pirates Cove Cottage- More info 4500-4750
Bedrooms:2 
Sleeps:4 
Treetops Weekly Rent Range   
Treetops- This is a small comfortable centrally located cottage. Easy walk to center of town and Hay Harbor Club. Convenient to ferry, Hay Harbor Golf Club and Fishers Island Yacht Club. More info 4400-4400
Bedrooms:3 
Sleeps:5 
Pumphouse Weekly Rent Range   
Pumphouse- More info 4500-4500
Bedrooms:2 
Sleeps:5 
Oceanhill Weekly Rent Range   
Oceanhill- More info 4500-4500
Bedrooms:3 
Sleeps:6 
West Harbor House Weekly Rent Range   
West Harbor House- More info 7500-7500
Bedrooms:3 
Sleeps:6 
Osprey Hill Cottage Weekly Rent Range   
Osprey Hill Cottage- More info 8100-8100
Bedrooms:3 
Sleeps:6 
Braun House Weekly Rent Range   
Braun House- More info 7400-7400
Bedrooms:3 
Sleeps:6 
Leeway Weekly Rent Range   
Leeway- More info 10000-10000
Bedrooms:4 
Sleeps:7 
Osprey Hill Weekly Rent Range   
Osprey Hill- This great house has a wonderful open floor plan with vaulted ceilings . The view from the living, master bedroom and queen bedroom is spectacular looking out towards Block Island and Long Island Sound. This well appointed house, located in a private location and just a short drive to excellent beaches and fishing spots, is a great retreat for the family. The two bedroom suite downstairs has a private patio. The master bedroom suite upstairs has a dressing room with large walk-in closet, bathroom and private deck. The dining room has a built-in 6 burner/3 zone gas grill and the kitchen includes a 6 burner gas stove top with hidden vent, double oven with convection, and two dishwashers. There is a full laundry room on the first floor. In addition, there is a guest house with one bedroom, large walk-in closet, bathroom and living room. More info 10800-18500
Bedrooms:5 
Sleeps:8 
Finan by the Sea Weekly Rent Range   
Finan by the Sea- With a lovely front porch, large private backyard with generous deck, you'll feel right at home in this 2006 four-bedroom cape. Tucked into a lovely quiet street behind the grand houses of Officer's Row, Winthrop Cape offers safety and serenity in a family-friendly package that's hard to resist. This house has a two week minimum More info 11100-18500
Bedrooms:5 
Sleeps:8 
Just Right Weekly Rent Range   
Just Right- Hydrangea Halll is a spacious and updated 4 bedroom, 1.75 bath house which is ready for your summer enjoyment. Nice location and spacious rooms make this house a perfect place for a large family summer getaway. This home is fully equipped, large and bright. More info 6050-6655
Bedrooms:4 
Sleeps:8 
Milliken House Weekly Rent Range   
Milliken House- Offering fabulous views of Fishers Island Sound, including Latimer Light, this private and secluded home is deeply set back on a picturesque 1.43 acres over looking the 8th fairway of the Fishers Island Club. The open floor plan, high ceilings, fireplace and ample outdoor spaces make this spacious home an ideal vacation rental. More info 10000-10500
Bedrooms:4 
Sleeps:8 
Hydrangea House Weekly Rent Range   
Hydrangea House- More info 7100-7100
Bedrooms:4 
Sleeps:8 
Oyster Barn Weekly Rent Range   
Oyster Barn- More info 15000-15000
Bedrooms:5 
Sleeps:8 
Highball Weekly Rent Range   
Highball- This great three season house has a wonderful open floor plan. The view from the kitchen, living and dining area is spectacular looking out towards Block Island and Long Island. The outside porch runs completely along the entire south side of the house with access from three bedrooms and the living area. One of the bedrooms has built in bunks as well as a pair of twin beds. There is also a loft that is accessible from the hallway that is fun for kids and athletic adults as well. This house, located in a private location high above the Fishers Island Golf course and a short drive to excellent beaches and fishing spots, is a great retreat for the family. More info 7500-7500
Bedrooms:3 
Sleeps:8 
Madeline Cottage Weekly Rent Range   
Madeline Cottage- More info 6500-6500
Bedrooms:4 
Sleeps:8 
Yellow House Weekly Rent Range   
Yellow House- One of the coveted houses along historic Officer's Row, the Yellow House offers amentities you'd expect in a modern house, while being a beautifully kept 1902 officer's home in the Fort H. G. Wright neighborhood. With a cozy fireplace in the newly crafted kitchen and a back porch that offers a sense of peace, this house is a perfect home away from home. The attention to detail is breathtaking and fully captures the Fishers Island atmosphere. More info 8500-8500
Bedrooms:4 
Sleeps:8 
FI Getaway Weekly Rent Range   
FI Getaway- More info 3600-3600
Bedrooms:4 
Sleeps:8 
Holiday Hill Weekly Rent Range   
Holiday Hill- Holiday Hill is a spacious 5 bedroom, 4 bath house which is ready for your summer enjoyment. Nice location and spacious rooms make this house a perfect place for a large family summer getaway. This home is fully equipped, large and bright. More info 8250-8250
Bedrooms:8 
Sleeps:10 
The Laughing Place Weekly Rent Range   
The Laughing Place- Carroll House is a spacious and updated 7 bedroom, 2 bath house which is ready for your summer enjoyment. Nice location and spacious rooms make this house a perfect place for a large family summer getaway. This home is fully equipped, large and bright. More info 7000-7000
Bedrooms:7 
Sleeps:10 

Prev 1  2  Next